Bury a friend, bury a band
A look at the importance of friendship vis-a-vis Uncle Tupelo's last album, Anodyne.
I've been teasing a review of what's probably my favorite album ever, Uncle Tupelo's 1994 farewell effort Anodyne, but not a review in the sense of "is this a good album?" or "you should listen to this." It started with me exploring why Anodyne hits so hard with me, especially since I love their first three albums almost as much.
To understand Anodyne you need a little background on Uncle Tupelo. The band formed in the late 1980s in Belleville, Illinois, a town of roughly 40,000 people located 15 miles southeast of St. Louis. Co-founders Jay Farrar and Jeff Tweedy would famously rise from the ashes of their breakup to form two inarguably more commercially successful bands – Farrar's Son Volt and Tweedy's Wilco. But a lot happened between Day 1 and May 1, 1994, when they played their final show at Mississippi Nights in St. Louis.
(Most of what I'm about to share re. their backstory comes from two excellent books, Greg Kot's Learning How to Die and Tweedy's own Let's Go (So We Can Get Back). Given that Jay refused to participate in either project, the official story of Uncle Tupelo's breakup is extremely Jeff-centric. I believe him to be a reliable narrator, but he also spent much of their early days in a haze of liquor and painkillers, so much so that he quit drinking in the early-90s, only to fall deeper into addiction due to the opioids he took to manage his frequent migraines. He's spoken and written openly of his addictions and says he's been completely sober since the early 2000s. But substance abuse and migraines can both play tricks with one's memory, so take that for what it's worth.)
Jay and his brother Wade were big music guys growing up. Jay and Jeff met in high school and the three played in a couple garage-type bands. Jeff took up the bass, in part because Jay was already on his way to becoming one of the great rock guitarists of all time. Jeff and Jay went on to form Uncle Tupelo and released their first album, No Depression, in 1990. Taking its name from a Depression-era classic by the Carter Family, it signaled a band putting its own twist on the grunge scene emerging out of Seattle. In addition to crunching guitars, they added acoustic elements – fiddle, harmonica, etc. – to create a sound that was equally old-fashioned and of the current moment.
From the start, it was clear that Jay viewed Uncle Tupelo as his band, with Jeff merely along for the ride. The two split songwriting duties roughly 2-to-1 on the debut album, with each taking lead vocals on his own songs. And that's where the discrepancy between the two was most evident. Jeff's voice had not truly come into its own yet – even at his best, Jeff will never be confused with Pavarotti or Plant, but on No Depression he sounds like a little kid still trying to figure out the toy microphone he got for Christmas. Meanwhile, I'm pretty sure that by the time he started Kindergarten, Jay's voice sounded like a byproduct of two packs of Winstons and a fifth of Jack Daniels a day, with all the snarl and growl and texture desired in a rock-and-roll front man.
But as Jeff became more comfortable with his voice – both literally and metaphorically – his role in the band started to grow. Songwriting duties were split more equally on their next two albums, and Uncle Tupelo hired a bass player as Jeff moved to mostly rhythm guitar.
The changing dynamics of the band also changed the nature of Jeff and Jay's friendship. Jay presumably felt threatened by Jeff being seen by others as more or less his equal. There was also an accusation of Jeff making a drunken pass at Jay's girlfriend, about which Jay hasn't spoken publicly while Jeff's recall of the incident is decidedly hazy.
The tension between the two boiled over in the writing of Anodyne. Song by song, the album describes the excruciating process of a friendship falling apart. And I think that might be what hits me the hardest of all. When I first got into Uncle Tupelo, they'd split up already and I didn't know anything about their history. So to me, the songs on Anodyne sounded like traditional breakup songs – as in, a romantic relationship breaking up.
But that's not the case. This album is clearly about two friends looking back at what they once shared and exploring how it all fell apart. They're hollering at each other from across the divide, knowing that it's too late for their words to save any shred of their friendship. To me, that's an even more powerful gut-punch.
I mean, most of us have gone through a number of romantic interests – everything from minor dalliances to longer-term partnerships – before we found the person with whom we decided we wanted to share a mortgage. But how many true friends do you have? And how often do you actually lose a friend? I'm fortunate that I'd need both hands to count the number of people I count as true friends, but I couldn't bear to see one of them turn their back on me or to feel the need to cut one of them loose. It's only happened at most a couple times in my life, and the memories are still painful.
The whole situation came to a head when the band made its network television debut with a guest slot on Conan O'Brien's old NBC show on February 21, 1994. Jay was reportedly furious that their record label demanded that they play "The Long Cut," one of Jeff's songs. Apparently Jay was already feeling constrained by the demands of their first major-label contract, but picking one of Jeff's songs for their network debut was a bridge too far. Just 10 weeks later, the band was history.
It got so bad that on their final tour, Jay refused to sing backing vocals on Jeff's songs. You can see in the video of their last concert, Jay pretty much stares at his feet and crunches out chords during all of Jeff's songs, with future Wilco bassist John Stirratt heroically stepping up with the harmonies. Kind of a dick move, if you ask me. But so is making a pass at your best friend's girlfriend, so I get it.
After that final gig, the other members of the final UT lineup – Stirratt, drummer Ken Coomer and I-can-play-anything-with-a-string Max Johnston – joined Tweedy in launching Wilco. Meanwhile, Farrar had plenty of connections around the country, helping him form a killer band in Son Volt. The rest is a story for another time. Now, without further delay, a few words about Anodyne ...
Oh god, he's gonna go through this song-by-song ...
Yeah, but I'll try to keep my comments brief. If you want to listen along at home, fire up your favorite streaming service, drop the needle on Side A Track 1, turn on your CD player, or just click here.
- "Slate"
I've always found Jeff's lyrics, especially in his UT days, to be much more accessible. Jay's more of a poet. You can spend hours trying to figure out what he means in most of his songs. But sometimes he can be remarkably direct:
What the hell were we thinking
Before the fire burned out?
I can't find you now
Didn't know you then - "Acuff-Rose"
I see this as Jeff's way of proving to Jay his C&W bona fides. "Oh, you think you're country? Let me tell you about a couple of my friends, Mr. Acuff and Mr. Rose." - "The Long Cut"
In addition to being the song that broke the camel's back for Jay, it's a total banger. I love Coomer's work here – not especially intricate but vital to the song's hard-driving vibe. Lyrically, this seems to be Jeff's attempt to show that he wanted to work it out and keep the band going. - "Give Back the Key to my Heart"
If you get a chance to record one of Doug Sahm's songs alongside Doug Sahm himself, you take it. - "Chickamauga"
Named for one of the bloodiest battles in the US Civil War, Jay makes clear his thoughts about the current vibe of the relationship.
When jousting is for pleasure
And pleasure is way out of hand
The time is ripe for getting out while we still can - "New Madrid"
In late 1811 and early 1812, a series of earthquakes flattened New Madrid, Missouri, a small town on the Mississippi River way down where Missouri, Kentucky and Tennessee meet. The earthquakes indeed made the river burn and run backwards, according to witnesses. And Mr. Browning was a guy named Iben Browning who predicted another two-day series of earthquakes would hit the New Madrid fault in 1990. Uncle Tupelo's first album came out in 1990. Four years later they were straddling the fault line themselves. Maybe the real earthquakes were the friends we lost along the way? - "Anodyne"
Per Merriam-Webster, there are two definitions for the word anodyne. The more common meaning is something inoffensive and predictable, even boring. It can also mean something that alleviates pain. In Jay's mind, perhaps the band had become the first definition, which is why he needs to leave to find the second definition.
He also seems hung up on having to share power with Jeff:
Two fingers on the trigger
Can break the heart of any day
Foolish to believe
It'd turn out okay - "We've Been Had"
Jeff could have called this "I've Been Had" and it would've been right on the nose. Also, Jay never came across as a real outgoing guy. But here, Jeff calls him out for being a poser whose day of reckoning is coming:
But every star that hides on the back of the bus
Is just waiting for his cover to be blown - "Fifteen Keys"
This strikes me as someone who's had more than enough of your bullshit, Jeff!
Silver spikes and mace displayed in your eyes
Fearlessness cannot fathom what's on your mind
Been there, no luck at all, nothing left to lose
Been there, no luck at all, nothing left to lose
I've been there - "High Water"
I mean ...
We quote each other only when we're wrong
We tear out the threads, move along
Can't seem to find common ground
I can see the sand and it's running out - "No Sense in Lovin'"
Musically, this is basically the first Wilco song. Tell me this wouldn't fit right in on A.M.
As far as the lyrics, I'm actually surprised Jay let this one go on the album. Unless he just didn't give a damn by that point. I've seen celebrity roasts that have treated the guest of honor better.
And there's no sense in lovin'
Anyone who hates themself
(Demerits for using a made-up word at the end.) - "Steal the Crumbs"
Just one of the saddest songs I've ever heard.
Never thought once to ask how's the temperature
Too busy with the finer points
Of each struggle we're after
No more will I see you
No more will I see you